Can Renewables Completely Replace Non-Renewables?

As the world grapples with the effects of climate change and the depletion of fossil fuels, the question of whether renewable energy can completely replace non-renewable energy sources is increasingly vital. With mounting pressures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, decarbonize economies, and ensure sustainable energy for future generations, the prospect of a renewable energy future is more appealing than ever. However, several technical, economic, and political challenges remain. In this blog, we will explore the potential for renewables to replace non-renewables, backed by data, examples, and expert perspectives.

The State of Global Energy

Before examining whether renewables can entirely replace non-renewables, it’s essential to understand the current state of global energy consumption. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), as of 2023, fossil fuels still account for around 80% of the global energy supply, with oil, coal, and natural gas leading the charge. This reliance on fossil fuels results in significant environmental impacts, including air pollution, habitat destruction, and climate change.

• Global Energy Mix (2023):

This dominance of fossil fuels is a legacy of industrialization, with energy systems built around non-renewables that are relatively cheap and reliable, but environmentally destructive.

The Rise of Renewables

Renewable energy sources, particularly solar, wind, and hydropower, have grown exponentially over the last two decades. The global installed capacity for renewable energy reached a record 3,400 GW in 2023, with solar photovoltaics (PV) and wind power driving the bulk of this growth. Solar capacity alone increased by over 20% from 2022 to 2023, and wind energy added more than 100 GW in 2023.

These rapid advancements in renewable energy technologies have brought down costs significantly. For example, the cost of solar energy has dropped by nearly 90% over the last decade​.

While these developments are encouraging, the question remains: Can these renewable sources meet the global energy demand on their own?

The Challenges of Renewables Replacing Non-Renewables

1. Intermittency and Reliability:
   One of the most significant hurdles for renewable energy is intermittency. Unlike fossil fuels, which provide a constant and reliable power source, wind and solar are variable and depend on weather conditions. For example, solar energy is unavailable at night and can be affected by seasonal fluctuations, while wind power is intermittent, depending on wind speeds. To fully replace fossil fuels, we would need reliable energy sources that can provide continuous power.
   Solution: One potential solution is energy storage. Technologies like batteries and pumped hydro storage are crucial to storing excess energy generated during periods of high production, which can then be used when renewable output is low. However, current storage technologies are still limited in terms of scale and cost, although improvements are expected in the coming years.

2. Energy Density:
   Fossil fuels like coal, oil, and natural gas are energy-dense, meaning they provide a large amount of energy from a small volume. For example, one ton of coal can generate about 24 MWh of electricity, whereas wind and solar require large land areas and favorable conditions to produce comparable amounts of energy. This discrepancy in energy density makes it challenging to replace fossil fuels, especially for sectors like heavy industry and transportation.
   Solution: Technological innovations such as advanced biofuels and hydrogen may provide high-energy-density alternatives to fossil fuels in hard-to-decarbonize sectors like aviation and shipping.

3. Infrastructure and Investment:
   Replacing fossil fuels with renewables requires massive investments in new infrastructure. For example, the energy grid must be modernized to handle the variable nature of renewable power, and new power plants, storage systems, and transmission lines must be built. The International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) estimates that $131 trillion in investments will be needed to achieve a fully renewable energy future by 2050​.

4. Global Disparities and Political Will:
   While renewable energy technologies are rapidly advancing, their adoption varies significantly across regions. Developed countries, such as those in Europe and North America, have invested heavily in renewables. In contrast, developing nations, particularly in Africa and Asia, still rely heavily on coal and oil for their energy needs. Achieving a global transition to renewables will require international cooperation and substantial investment in technology transfer and infrastructure development in these regions.
   Example: China, which is the world’s largest emitter of carbon dioxide, has made significant strides in renewable energy deployment, with over 400 GW of solar and wind power installed by 2023. However, China still derives a large portion of its energy from coal, which represents around 56% of its energy mix​.

Can Renewables Completely Replace Non-Renewables?

1. Renewable Energy Growth:
   Renewables are undoubtedly growing rapidly. The International Energy Agency (IEA) projects that by 2030, renewables could account for 50% of the global power generation capacity, and by 2050, renewables could meet nearly 90% of global electricity demand​. Countries like Denmark and Germany have already achieved impressive results. Denmark, for example, produced 53.6% of its electricity from wind in 2022​.

2. Energy Transition in Different Sectors:
   Replacing fossil fuels in power generation is relatively achievable, but achieving full decarbonization in other sectors is more challenging. The transport sector, especially aviation, shipping, and heavy trucking, depends heavily on liquid fuels, and even with advances in electric vehicles (EVs), there is still a long way to go in terms of infrastructure and battery technology to fully replace gasoline and diesel.

• Electric Vehicles (EVs): The global EV market has grown significantly, with over 10 million EVs sold in 2023. The shift to EVs can reduce the reliance on oil for personal transport .

• Hard-to-Decarbonize Sectors: In aviation, ships, and heavy industries, hydrogen and biofuels may play a crucial role. However, these technologies are still in early stages of development.

3. The Role of Nuclear Energy:
   Some experts argue that a mix of renewables and nuclear power will be necessary to replace fossil fuels. Nuclear energy provides a reliable, low-carbon source of energy that could help fill the gaps left by intermittent renewable sources. Countries like France, which generates about 70% of its electricity from nuclear, rely on it as a cornerstone of their clean energy strategy.
   Example: The U.S. has made strides in increasing its use of renewables, but nuclear still supplies about 20% of the nation’s electricity​.

While the complete replacement of non-renewables with renewable energy presents significant challenges, it is not entirely out of reach. The technical, economic, and political barriers to this transition are substantial, but they are not insurmountable. A mix of renewables, advanced storage technologies, energy efficiency measures, and in some cases, nuclear power and biofuels, could form the foundation of a sustainable energy future.

Governments, industries, and consumers must all play a role in accelerating this transition. Increased investments in renewable energy technologies, grid infrastructure, and energy storage are essential. Moreover, policies supporting innovation and fostering international cooperation will be crucial in ensuring that renewable energy can meet global demand.

Are you a landowner or an industrial roof owner? Join Telkes in leading the green energy revolution! Let us help you turn your property into a sustainable energy solution that benefits the planet. Visit Telkes today and discover how you can contribute to a cleaner future while maximizing your property's potential. Together, we can power a brighter, greener world!