The Role of International Trade Law in the Energy Transition
The global shift from fossil fuels to renewable energy is one of the most critical actions humanity can take to combat climate change. This energy transition requires not only technological advancements and financial investments but also significant changes to legal frameworks, including international trade law. Trade law, as Henok Asmelash argues in his article The Role of International Trade Law in the Energy Transition, plays a pivotal role in either accelerating or hindering this transition.
What is the Energy Transition?
The energy transition refers to replacing carbon-intensive fossil fuels like coal, oil, and natural gas with renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power. Fossil fuels currently make up 82% of the global energy supply and are responsible for two-thirds of greenhouse gas emissions.
International agreements such as the Paris Agreement and the Glasgow Climate Pact call for urgent action, including phasing out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies and accelerating the adoption of renewable energy. However, despite these commitments, fossil fuel subsidies remain pervasive, and the speed of the transition falls short of what is needed to prevent catastrophic climate change.
While much focus has been on technological and financial barriers, Asmelash highlights an often-overlooked factor: international trade law.
How Trade Law Intersects with the Energy Transition
International trade law governs how countries use trade measures like tariffs, subsidies, and standards. These laws aim to ensure free and fair trade but were largely designed for a fossil-fuel-driven economy. As a result, they are not well-equipped to support the shift to renewable energy.
Trade measures impacting the energy transition fall into two categories:
Pro-energy transition measures: Policies like renewable energy subsidies or fossil fuel tariff reforms that promote renewables and discourage fossil fuels.
Anti-energy transition measures: Policies like subsidies for fossil fuels or tariffs on renewable energy technologies that delay the transition.
Unfortunately, current trade laws often treat these two categories similarly, ignoring their environmental implications.
Challenges Posed by Existing Trade Laws
1. Non-Discrimination Rules: The WTO’s non-discrimination principle prevents countries from treating imported and domestic “like products” differently. This creates challenges for policies favoring renewable energy over fossil fuels. For example, renewable electricity and fossil-fuel-based electricity are often considered “like products,” making it difficult to promote renewables without breaching trade rules.
2. Tariffs and Trade Barriers: Renewable energy technologies like solar panels and wind turbines often face high tariffs, increasing their cost and making them less competitive. Fossil fuels, on the other hand, typically benefit from very low tariffs. Efforts to reduce tariffs on renewable energy products, such as the Environmental Goods Agreement (EGA), have stalled, perpetuating this imbalance.
3. Subsidies: Governments use subsidies to support renewable energy, but such measures are frequently challenged under WTO rules. Ironically, fossil fuel subsidies—despite being environmentally harmful—face little scrutiny. This imbalance undermines global efforts to reduce emissions and transition to sustainable energy.
4. Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs): The WTO’s Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement often makes it difficult for developing countries to access renewable energy technologies. Most patents are concentrated in developed countries, creating significant barriers for poorer nations trying to adopt and innovate in renewable energy.
5. Technical Standards: While harmonized technical standards can facilitate the adoption of renewable technologies, inconsistent regulations across countries often create barriers to trade. For example, differing standards for wind energy products or biofuels increase costs and slow the transition.
Opportunities for Reform
To align trade laws with the energy transition, Asmelash proposes several reforms:
1. Adjust Subsidy Rules: WTO rules should explicitly support renewable energy subsidies while imposing stricter controls on fossil fuel subsidies. Reclassifying renewable subsidies as “non-actionable” could protect them from legal challenges.
2. Reform Tariff Policies: Countries should reduce tariffs on renewable energy technologies and consider imposing higher tariffs on fossil fuels to make renewables more competitive.
3. Promote Green Public Procurement: Governments should prioritize renewable energy in public procurement policies. However, WTO rules limiting discrimination in procurement need to be relaxed to allow this.
4. Harmonize Technical Standards: The WTO should collaborate with organizations like the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) to harmonize standards for renewable technologies, reducing trade barriers and promoting global adoption.
5. Enhance Technology Transfer: The TRIPS Agreement should be reformed to improve access to renewable energy technologies in developing countries. Mechanisms like compulsory licensing and public-private partnerships could play a vital role in ensuring equitable access.
New Approaches: Plurilateral Agreements and Informal Initiatives
Given the challenges in achieving multilateral reforms, countries are exploring alternative approaches such as plurilateral agreements and informal initiatives. Examples include:
The Environmental Goods Agreement (EGA): Focused on reducing tariffs on renewable energy products.
The Agreement on Climate Change, Trade, and Sustainability (ACCTS): Aims to eliminate fossil fuel subsidies and promote environmental goods.
While promising, these initiatives often exclude developing countries, raising concerns about global equity and inclusivity.
The energy transition is not just a technological or financial challenge but also a legal one. International trade law has significant potential to support or hinder this transition. To ensure trade laws facilitate a sustainable energy future, urgent reforms are needed to:
Support renewable energy subsidies.
Liberalize trade in renewable technologies.
Promote equitable access to energy innovations.
By addressing these gaps, international trade law can play a pivotal role in shaping a just and effective energy transition, helping the world move closer to a sustainable future.
Are you a landowner or an industrial roof owner? Join Telkes in leading the green energy revolution! Let us help you turn your property into a sustainable energy solution that benefits the planet. Visit Telkes today and discover how you can contribute to a cleaner future while maximizing your property's potential. Together, we can power a brighter, greener world!
